Title Holder |
Defeated |
Date |
Location |
| Taka Michinoku | Brian Christopher | Dec 7/97 | Springfield, Massachusetts |
| Christian | Taka Michinoku | Oct 18/98 | Chicago, Illinois |
| Dwayne Gill | Christian | Nov 19/98 | Columbus, Ohio |
| Essa Rios | Gillberg [Dwayne Gill] | Feb 8/00 | Austin, Texas |
| Dean Malenko | Essa Rios | Mar 13/00 | East Rutherford, New Jersey |
| Scotty Too Hotty | Dean Malenko | Apr 17/00 | State College, Pennsylvania |
| Dean Malenko | Scotty Too Hotty | Apr 25/00 | Charlotte, North Carolina |